The Two Words That Determine Your Payout
Most homeowners never think about the fine print of their insurance policy. Until a storm puts a hole in their roof. Then one detail buried on your declarations page determines whether you pay $1,000 out of pocket or $8,000 or more.
That detail is your loss settlement type. Specifically, whether your roof is covered on a Replacement Cost Value (RCV) basis or an Actual Cash Value (ACV) basis.
We've worked with hundreds of Northeast Ohio homeowners through the insurance claims process. The single biggest factor in how much they pay out of pocket. More than the size of the damage, more than the insurance company they're with. Is this one policy distinction. If you're preparing to file, our step-by-step guide on how to file a roof insurance claim covers the full process.
Replacement Cost Value (RCV) Explained
RCV in one sentence:
Your insurance pays the full cost to replace your damaged roof with materials of like kind and quality. Regardless of how old your roof is. Your only cost is your deductible.
With an RCV policy, your insurance company agrees to pay what it actually costs to put a new roof on your home today. If your 15-year-old roof gets destroyed by hail, they don't pay you for a 15-year-old roof. They pay for a brand new one.
The process works in two checks:
- 1Initial check (ACV amount): After the adjuster approves your claim, the insurance company sends your first check. This covers the replacement cost minus your deductible and minus a depreciation holdback. Think of this as the "get started" payment.
- 2Completion check (recoverable depreciation): After your contractor finishes the roof and submits a completion certificate, the insurance company releases the depreciation they held back. This second check can be $2,000 to $5,000 or more.
Most standard Ohio homeowners policies (HO-3 policies) include RCV coverage for roofs that are less than 15 to 20 years old. If you purchased a standard policy through a reputable agent, there's a good chance you have RCV, but you should verify before assuming.
Schedule Free Inspection
Most appointments available within 48 hours. No obligation.
100% Free | No Obligation | Same-Day Response
Actual Cash Value (ACV) Explained
ACV in one sentence:
Your insurance pays the replacement cost minus depreciation based on your roof's age. The older your roof, the less you get.
ACV policies account for the age and wear of your roof when calculating your payout. The insurance company figures out what it would cost to replace your roof today, then subtracts a percentage based on how old it is. On a roof that's halfway through its expected lifespan, that subtraction can be 40 to 60 percent of the total value.
For a 15-year-old roof with 25-year rated shingles, the insurance company depreciates roughly 60 percent of the replacement value. On a $15,000 roof, that means your insurance check might only cover $6,000 to $7,000. Leaving you responsible for the rest.
ACV policies are more common than most homeowners realize. You're more likely to have ACV coverage if:
- Your roof is over 15 to 20 years old
- You have a budget or economy-tier policy
- Your home has a history of prior roof claims
- You purchased the cheapest available policy when closing on your home
- Your insurer switched your roof to ACV at renewal due to age
Unlike RCV, there is no second check with an ACV policy. What you get upfront is all you get. There is no recoverable depreciation. The depreciation is permanent.
The Real-World Difference: A $12,000 Example
Numbers make this concrete. Let's walk through the same roof replacement under both policy types.
RCV Policy
- Roof replacement cost: $15,000
- Your deductible: $1,000
- Insurance pays: $14,000
- You pay: $1,000
ACV Policy
- Roof replacement cost: $15,000
- Depreciation (15yr / 25yr life = 60%): -$9,000
- ACV payout before deductible: $6,000
- Your deductible: -$1,000
- Insurance pays: $5,000
- You pay: $10,000
That's a $9,000 difference based on one policy checkbox.
Same storm. Same damage. Same house. Same contractor. The only variable is whether your declarations page says "Replacement Cost" or "Actual Cash Value."
Recoverable Depreciation: The Check Most People Don't Know About
If you have an RCV policy, the claims process involves two separate payments. The first check arrives after the adjuster approves your claim. This initial payment equals the replacement cost minus your deductible and minus the depreciation holdback.
Many homeowners assume that first check is the entire payout. It's not. The second check. The recoverable depreciation. Is released after you complete the roof replacement and your contractor submits proof of completion to the insurance company.
Here is what happens in practice:
- 1
Adjuster approves the claim
The insurance company calculates the full replacement cost (say $15,000), subtracts your deductible ($1,000) and depreciation holdback ($4,000), and sends you Check 1 for $10,000.
- 2
Contractor completes the roof
Your roofing contractor finishes the installation and provides a completion certificate or final invoice showing the work is done.
- 3
You submit completion docs to insurance
Send the completion certificate to your insurance company. They verify the work was completed.
- 4
Insurance releases Check 2
The insurance company sends a second check for the $4,000 depreciation holdback. Your total payout: $14,000. Your total out-of-pocket: $1,000 (your deductible).
Don't leave money on the table.
We've seen homeowners forget to submit their completion paperwork and miss out on $3,000 to $5,000 in recoverable depreciation. A good contractor handles this step for you. and we always do.
How to Check Your Policy Right Now
You don't need to wait for a storm to find out what kind of coverage you have. Here's how to check in the next 10 minutes:
- 1
Find your declarations page
This is the summary page of your homeowners policy. Usually the first 2 to 3 pages. It lists your coverage amounts, deductibles, and policy terms. You can find it in your email, your insurance company's online portal, or the paper copy in your files.
- 2
Search for "loss settlement" or "roof coverage"
Look for sections labeled "Loss Settlement," "Dwelling Coverage," "Roof Surfacing," or "Roof Schedule." This is where your policy specifies RCV or ACV for your roof.
- 3
Call your agent if it's unclear
Call your insurance agent and ask directly: "Is my roof covered on a Replacement Cost Value or Actual Cash Value basis?" This is a simple question they can answer in 30 seconds.
If you discover you have ACV coverage and your roof is under 15 years old, ask your agent about upgrading to RCV. The cost increase is typically $50 to $150 per year. An investment that could save you $5,000 to $10,000 on your next claim. You should also know about Ohio's roof matching law, which requires insurers to match materials on partial repairs.
What If You Have ACV?
Having an ACV policy is not the end of the world. It still provides meaningful coverage. Just not full replacement. Here are your options:
Upgrade your policy before the next storm season
Talk to your insurance agent about switching to RCV. If your roof is in good condition and under 15 to 20 years old, most insurers will approve the upgrade. Do this before storm season, not after damage occurs. Changes take effect at your next renewal.
Budget for a larger out-of-pocket share
If you can't switch to RCV, know that you'll likely pay more out of pocket on a claim. Set aside funds in a home maintenance reserve so you're prepared. Even a partial insurance payout is better than paying for a full roof replacement on your own.
Still file claims when damage occurs
ACV coverage is still real coverage. On a newer roof, the depreciation may be minimal. Even on an older roof, an ACV check for $5,000 to $7,000 significantly reduces your total cost. Don't skip filing just because you have ACV.
Consider a higher-deductible RCV policy as an alternative
Some homeowners can get RCV coverage by accepting a higher deductible. Say $2,500 instead of $1,000. You pay more on small claims, but you're fully covered on a major loss. Run the numbers with your agent to see if this makes sense.
Make sure supplements are filed
Whether you have RCV or ACV, your contractor should submit supplements for any items the adjuster missed. On ACV policies, every additional dollar in the approved scope means more money in your pocket. An experienced claims contractor fights for every line item.
Not Sure About Your Coverage? We'll Review Your Claim Free
Whether you have RCV, ACV, or aren't sure. We'll inspect your roof, review your policy details, and walk you through exactly what to expect before you file. No cost, no obligation, no pressure.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I switch from ACV to RCV on my homeowners policy?
In most cases, yes. Contact your insurance agent and ask about upgrading your roof coverage from Actual Cash Value to Replacement Cost Value. The cost increase is typically $50 to $150 per year, depending on your roof's age and condition. Some insurers require a roof inspection before making the switch, and roofs over 20 years old may not qualify for RCV coverage.
What is recoverable depreciation on a roof insurance claim?
Recoverable depreciation is the portion of your claim that your insurance company withholds until the roof replacement is complete. On an RCV policy, your insurer initially pays the depreciated (ACV) amount. After your contractor finishes the work and submits a completion certificate, the insurance company releases the remaining depreciation amount in a second check. This second payment can be $2,000 to $5,000 or more.
How is roof depreciation calculated by insurance companies?
Insurance companies calculate roof depreciation based on the age of the roof relative to its expected lifespan. For example, a 15-year-old architectural shingle roof with a 30-year rated life would be depreciated approximately 50%. The formula is typically: (age of roof / expected lifespan) x replacement cost = depreciation amount. Some insurers use a straight-line method while others use tables that account for material type and condition.
What if my insurance payout doesn't cover the full cost of my roof replacement?
If you have an ACV policy and the payout falls short, you have several options. First, make sure your contractor submits a supplement for any missed items or price discrepancies. Second, check whether you're eligible to upgrade to RCV before the next storm season. Third, ask your contractor about financing options. Finally, even with ACV, the payout reduces your out-of-pocket cost significantly compared to paying entirely on your own.
Related reading: How to File a Roof Insurance Claim · Does Insurance Cover Hail Damage in Ohio?
Our services: Insurance Claim Help · Storm Damage Repair · Schedule Free Inspection
